Well, the big event is finally here. An event several months in the making and the sequel to the great Crisis on Infinite Earths Read on for spoilers.

Was Infinite Crisis worth the wait? So far, I’d have to say yes. Despite the cliches (and all of there are here: the omniscient watchers, the pointless deaths, the angst, the last page reveal), I found myself enjoying it. I avoided nearly all the mini-series running up to this, but none of them seem all that necessary to have read. The universe is falling apart, and there’s only one person who can save it all.
Like every mega-crossover, this one starts with chaos: the Justice League has effectively been neutralized: Wonder Woman has killed Max Lord, Batman has unleashed killer robots, and Superman is doubting himself. The rest of the universe isn’t doing too hot, either: the Rann/Thanagar war has spilled into a wide-scale conflict; the Guardians of the Universe are trying to control things with the Green Lantern Corp, but it’s all spiralling out of control; Superboy has given up even trying to be a hero, tainted by his connection to Lex Luthor; OMACs are running about, killing without remorse; the Spectre is insane and has killed the wizard Shazam.
This first issue seems to ably recap most of the mini-series that came before. Much is glossed over, but you do get a sense of the craziness that’s been building up.
Then there’s the requisite hero deaths, to make us believe that this conflict is worse than anything we’ve seen before. The victims this time: the Freedom Fighters, of course. When I saw the preview with them in it, I knew it was coming. Result: Black Condor, possibly still alive; Phantom Lady, dead; Damage, possibly alive; Human Bomb, dead; Uncle Sam, likely dead; Ray, captured. On the villain side: Dr. Polaris, likely dead. It was the typical brutal fight scene that seem all the rage these days. The problem is that I didn’t care all that much. When you don’t see characters for a decade or so and they suddenly show up in a mega-crossover, you know what to expect.
Meanwhile, as the Freedom Fighters are freed from life, the big three, Superman, Batman and Wonder Woman, angst about various things up on the moon. Their interplay is interesting (and Batman gets in a great zinger about the last time Superman inspired people was when he was dead). Another perfunctory villain fight pops up for no real reason.
And the big payoff. The omniscient watchers are revealed, survivors of the previous Crisis: Alexander Luthor, the son of an alternate Earth’s Luthor (Earth-3, if I recall); the Superboy from Earth-Prime; the Earth-2 Lois Lane, and, the greatest hero of all: the Earth-2 Superman.
I was pleased as punch when I saw that last page. They’ve been signaling it for a while, and it’s pretty obvious to me that the Earth-2 Superman feels the heroes have squandered the new timeline and means to set things right. There’s also some type of personal connection with this Superman, as well: someone he apparently wants to save (the logical choice would be Power Girl, but I expect it will be more complicated).
The art is fine, nothing really amazing here. I opted to get the George Perez cover (a lame Jim Lee cover was also available, but looked awful). I wish Perez was doing the interiors, though. Phil Jimenez is fine, but nothing beats Perez pencils to me.
Oh, and we get a cool Nightwing/Starfire moment. Starfire is, of course, now doomed. Well, probably not. :) I just always cringe when characters I like show up in these things. The usually end up in bodybags by the end.
This entry was posted on Wednesday, October 12th, 2005 at 9:34 pm and is filed under DC Comics, Reviews. You can follow any responses to this entry through the RSS 2.0 feed.
The URI to TrackBack this entry is:
http://spandexjustice.com/2005/10/12/50/trackback

Responses to “Infinite Crisis #1”
I gotta disagree. I was really let down by this crisis. Aside from the Batman line you mentioned, the whole thing fell flat for me. And haven’t you had your fill of gray-side-burn-superman from Superman/Batman? For a year wait and some of the best talent in comics, I expected to be wowed like i was with countdown. I wasn’t.
October 13th, 2005 at 10:19 pm |
Hmm, perhaps since I haven’t been following Superman/Batman, I had no idea that the Earth-2 Superman was in there. I wasn’t impressed with Countdown at all, though (for one, it wasn’t even a complete story). I hope that Infinite Crisis at least tells a whole story. Maybe my standards are a little low these days.
October 14th, 2005 at 8:40 am |
Actually–I’m not sure we know which Superman that was in Superman/Batman. I’ve heard Earth-1 Superman or Kingdom Come Superman.
The Freedom Fighters were in that too, and they died ugly in that too. It was probably foreshadowing.
October 15th, 2005 at 4:27 pm |
I agree. They wait was worth it, but I hope they can sustain this momentum for six more issues.
October 17th, 2005 at 6:23 pm |
[...] Anyhoo, I watched GH back in the late 70s to early 80s, and have just learned that Rick Springfield is returning to the show, playing good old Dr. Noah Drake. Looks like Robin Scorpio is back, too. And I kinda can’t wait. I’m a sucker for old characters returning to anything: TV shows, music, movies, and comic books (just last week, a major character returned to the DC Comics universe, yay; and Kate Bush has a new single and video out, as well as a new album coming). [...]
October 17th, 2005 at 10:36 pm |